In the spring of 2021, Apple released a new Siri remote for Apple TV 4K (2nd generation), which is also compatible with Apple TV 4K (1st generation) as well as Apple TV HD. There are a few problems with the first generation Siri remote, which this new remote fixes. So for those who can afford its $59 purchase price, the new Siri remote is worth it.
Comparison chart
Apple TV Remote (1st Generation) versus Apple TV Remote (2nd Generation) comparison chartApple TV Remote (1st Generation)Apple TV Remote (2nd Generation)- current rating is 3.83/5
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
- current rating is 4.3/5
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
Problems with the first generation Siri remote
The 1st generation Siri remote for Apple TV HD and Apple TV 4K
.There were a few usability issues with the first generation Siri remote:
- It was perfectly symmetrical, so it was hard to know without looking which end was up. People often accidentally hit the Siri button.
- There was no way to easily fast-forward or rewind a few seconds. You could pause the video and use the scroll bar to but this does not give you fine-grained control.
- The Menu button was ambiguous. It worked as a Back button in most apps but was not consistent.
- The trackpad or touch surface of the remote is overly sensitive; it is easy to graze and can pause what you are watching.
Advantages of the second generation Siri remote
2nd generation Siri remote for Apple TV
The 2nd generation Siri remote for Apple TV is really the only remote you need. You can chuck away your other remotes like the Roku or TV remote.
- The clickpad ring on the second generation remote makes navigation a lot easier.
- The Mute button on the remote is very handy.
- It is less likely to be lost in couch cushions. It is easier to find compared to the tiny black first generation remote that tended to become easily hidden in couches and recliner crevices.
The new remote is a little heavier, bigger and colder, though. So some people may not like it. But for most people it is clearly the better choice.
Should I splurge on a standalone remote?
If you have an older Apple TV 4K or Apple TV HD, should you go out and buy the new second generation Siri Remote? If you can afford to, and if you pretty much use Apple TV rather than Roku or Fire TV, then yes, the second generation Siri remote is worth buying (check Amazon deal). The new remote makes it easier to navigate and use your Apple TV.
The 1st generation generation Siri remote only has a touch surface, which responds to both taps and swipes. The 2nd generation remote has both a clickpad, which responds to touch/swipes, as well as a clickpad ring that you can press or click.
It’s so, so, so much better. But the moment Apple showed off the second-generation Siri Remote, it was obvious that this would be a huge improvement over its detested predecessor. It’s easy to tell which way is right side up when you reach for it. The clickable touchpad area that dominated the upper third of the prior remote has been replaced by a more intuitive D-pad. The Siri button has been pushed to the remote’s right side, almost guaranteeing that you’ll never unintentionally trigger Apple’s voice assistant. And now there’s a proper power button for your TV.
Listing all of these “upgrades” on the new $59 Siri Remote really illustrates just how disappointing the old one that somehow lasted six years on the market was. Before this big redesign, the most Apple did in that time was to try to cure the “which side is up?” confusion by adding a white rim around one of the buttons. “Can’t innovate anymore, my ass.”
But this? This new Siri Remote is a very good remote. There’s nothing exceptional about it, but it’s functional, accessible, and painless to use. If you used those words to describe the original Siri Remote, you’d be in the minority.
9Verge Score
Apple Siri Remote (2nd gen)
$59
The Good
- Vastly improved design
- Includes power, volume, and mute buttons
- Buttons are nice and clicky
The Bad
- No remote locator feature
- Still with the Lightning connector? Really?
$59.00 at Apple$59.00 at B&H Photo$59.99 at Target$59.99 at Best Buy
It feels really nice, too. Apple makes the remote from a unibody aluminum shell that’s taller, heavier, and considerably thicker than the old Siri clicker. It’s slightly narrower than the black remote but still feels larger on the whole — and that’s a positive. The previous Siri remote was so thin that it was easily lost to the deepest reaches of the couch. I don’t see that being as much of a problem with the new, chunkier hardware.
The Siri Remote is in keeping with Apple’s renewed fondness for hard edges. With the remote gripped in hand, you never really feel the edges on the front, but you do at the back. The back metal is curved, but there’s still a hard edge at both sides. As long as you don’t squeeze the remote too tight, it should prove reasonably comfortable.
Apple has added power and mute buttons to the new Siri Remote.
Instead of putting what basically amounted to a trackpad on the top section of the remote, Apple has switched to a much more traditional directional pad. Within that circular D-pad is a touch-sensitive center button that still lets you swipe around content or move in any direction just like you could before. (And yes, you can still play with the subtle movement of app icons on the home screen by gently nudging your thumb around.) But some streaming apps didn’t work perfectly with that input method, so Apple is now including the far more precise D-pad.
This choose-your-preferred-navigation method — Apple calls it the “clickpad with touch surface” — has a very short learning curve. Initially, I would inadvertently activate the touchpad when I just meant to move my finger from down to up or vice versa on the D-pad. That didn’t last long, but if it winds up a bigger hassle for you, there’s an option in the remote’s settings menu to assign the center button to “click only,” which gives the D-pad all navigation duties.
Apple has also come up with a clever jogwheel function that lets you circle a finger around the outer ring to scrub through videos at faster or slower speeds depending on how quickly you’re thumbing around the circle. It’s a direct callback to the days of the iPod clickwheel and does a great job helping you land on an exact moment in a video.
The new clickpad is infinitely better than the prior touchpad.
The Siri button is now on the side, where you’re less likely to press it accidentally.
But I must confess something: I had an embarrassing few hours where I couldn’t figure out how to make this work. Eventually, I learned the trick: after pausing a video, you’ve got to rest your finger on the D-pad momentarily before you start circling around it. An animation will pop up in the progress bar (with a little dot that indicates where your finger is) to let you know you’re in jogwheel mode. If you just pause the video and immediately start the circular movement, it doesn’t do the right thing. Don’t be like me and unnecessarily factory reset your Apple TV 4K because of this.
The buttons themselves all have a satisfying click and don’t feel the least bit mushy. The clickpad is quieter when pressed than the buttons below it, which are each significantly noisier than any other remotes I had to compare against, be it for a Roku, Chromecast, or otherwise. Again, it’s not a problem unless you’re sensitive to that sort of thing, but you’ll absolutely hear the volume rocker when you’re turning up a certain scene in a movie or show. The Siri button on the side is whisper quiet; you still have to press and hold it down whenever you’re doing a voice command.
You might also have to overcome some muscle memory challenges since the mute button is now where play / pause was situated on the old remote. The “menu” button has been rebadged as “back” but does the same functions as before, which means, in most cases, the new icon makes a ton more sense. The buttons aren’t backlit, but it’s easy enough to memorize them by feel once you’ve used the remote for a while.
There’s a circular D-pad with a touchpad in the center.
But as good as the new Siri Remote is, it feels like Apple missed some opportunities that frankly seem like low-hanging fruit. The most glaring is that there’s no way to locate the remote if you’re unable to find it. As I said earlier, the bigger dimensions should make for fewer instances where the remote gets misplaced, but some way of having it alert you to its location would’ve been nice. “Hey Siri, where’s my remote?” seems like such an easy thing to make happen, but that voice query won’t do you any good or make the remote beep. And unlike Apple’s recently introduced AirTags, there’s no ultra-wideband chip in the remote to help pinpoint its position in a room. If you’re finding that the remote goes MIA constantly, you might just have to settle for a case that combines an AirTag with the Siri Remote. But having a simple, straightforward remote locator feature is one area where Roku objectively beats out Apple.
A less impactful gripe is the lack of an input button for switching between HDMI sources; the Apple TV automatically becomes the active input when you power it on or wake it from sleep. But an input button would’ve at least made life easier for people switching between an Apple TV and an Xbox or PlayStation. As a result, I just can’t quit my LG TV’s remote, much as I wish I could. Most of my devices automatically grab the TV’s attention when they’re switched on, but a button is foolproof.
This Siri Remote is substantially thicker than the previous one.
Hopefully it won’t go swimming in couch cushions as often.
I can complain about buttons being absent, but I can also praise Apple for the same reason: there are no branded shortcut buttons whatsoever on the Siri Remote. Not even Netflix can lock down its own button, whereas you’d be hard-pressed to find another streaming box remote without that logo somewhere.
AGREE TO CONTINUE: SIRI REMOTE (2ND GEN)
Every smart device now requires you to agree to a series of terms and conditions before you can use it — contracts that no one actually reads. It’s impossible for us to read and analyze every single one of these agreements. But we’re going to start counting exactly how many times you have to hit “agree” to use devices when we review them since these are agreements most people don’t read and definitely can’t negotiate.
The Siri Remote is an accessory to the Apple TV 4K and Apple TV HD. By setting those devices up, you’re agreeing to:
- Apple’s tvOS terms and conditions
- Apple’s warranty policy
- iCloud terms and conditions
- Game Center terms and conditions
You can optionally agree to:
- Share analytics data with Apple to “help improve its products and services.” This may include location data.
- Share app activity and crash data with tvOS developers through Apple.
The final tally is four mandatory agreements and two optional.
The Siri Remote still charges with Apple’s Lightning connector — despite now being thick enough to house a USB-C jack. USB seems more natural for this type of scenario, but what do I know? I’m just one man who’s elated to have a reliable, sensibly designed remote control again. Apple is going to keep doing Apple things. I was not able to test the new remote with third-party charging stands designed for the old one, but I wouldn’t be surprised if that industry catches up with the new design in the near future.
The right choice is clear.
The gyroscope and accelerometer from the previous Siri Remote are history, so you won’t be able to use this one for Apple Arcade games that rely on those sensors. But it’s unlikely many people were gaming with it to begin with; tvOS now supports many third-party gamepads, including the latest Xbox and PlayStation controllers, if you hadn’t heard.
Any way you slice it, the new Siri Remote is a win on every level. It’s inconceivable that we put up with the last one for so many years, but its time has come. And the remote control taking its place is extremely good at doing remote control things. Much as how Apple’s M1 MacBooks would have earned perfect scores if they’d had competent webcams, the Siri Remote would be flirting with perfection if it just had some way of letting you easily find the thing. Or if the buttons were backlit. My review of the new Apple TV 4K is coming soon, but if you’ve already got the last model, this is the only real must-have upgrade to go for.
Photography by Chris Welch / The Verge
Join the conversation
Most Popular
The golden age of the streaming wars has ended
Volkswagen has given a name to its pain, and it is ‘software’
Twitter suspends @ElonJet after Musk promises not to ban it
Westworld is leaving HBO Max
Jack Dorsey on Musk’s Twitter files: ‘There’s nothing to hide’
Verge Deals
/ Sign up for Verge Deals to get deals on products we've tested sent to your inbox daily.
Email (required)Sign up
By submitting your email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Notice. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.